Bhutan and India sign historic treaty


A moment in history

INDIA - BHUTAN TREATY 10 February, 2007 - Bhutan and India consolidated a new era of friendship and economic cooperation in a historic moment on February 8 by signing the India-Bhutan Friendship Treaty in New Delhi. His Majesty the King Jigme Khesar Namgyel Wangchuck signed the treaty with the Indian foreign minister, Mr. Pranab Mukherjee, in the presence of the Indian prime minister, Dr. Manmohan Singh, Bhutanese prime minister and foreign minister, Lyonpo Khandu Wangchuk, and a host of dignitaries from the two countries.

“The Treaty of Friendship truly reflects the unchanging and steadfast nature of the bonds of our friendship,” His Majesty said in a written statement. “In spite of the transformation in regional and global politics, as well as in our own relationship with the signing of this treaty, it is my belief that our ties will become even stronger as they grow more diverse with rapid economic growth in both countries and more intimate as people to people ties take centre stage.”

In essence the two countries updated the friendship treaty that was signed on August 8, 1949, in Darjeeling, India. Outdated by time, the new treaty portrayed a commitment by the two countries to face new realities. “It is not 1949 any more,” Mr. Pranab Mukherjee told Kuensel. “Today we want to change even the United Nations Security Council. Our two countries enjoy sovereignty and equality and, in this case, it reflects the excellent relations between India and Bhutan.”
In an official statement after the signing ceremony the government of India described the updating of the treaty as a historic moment in its relations with Bhutan and a reflection of the mutual desire to enhance the relationship to an even higher level of cooperation and goodwill. “Over several decades India’s relations with Bhutan have been an enduring element of our foreign policy,” the statement said. “India-Bhutan relations are today characterised by maturity, trust, respect, understanding and joint ventures in ever-expanding areas of activity.”

“We are watching history being made,” the Indian foreign secretary, Mr. Shiv Shankar Menon, told Kuensel. “The treaty reflects a new maturity in our relations. We have the key to build our future. Both our countries have developed, changed, and this reflects today’s state and our new capabilities.”

The updated treaty, discussed and drafted over the past few years by His Majesty King Jigme Singye Wangchuck and Indian leaders, has struck out a clause that required Bhutan to be “guided” by India in its foreign relations, and gives Bhutan the right to purchase arms and military equipment without consulting India. At the same time it emphasises that the two countries will not harm each other’s interests.

“It removes provisions that have become obsolete with time,” according to the Indian government statement. “It includes fresh provisions for consolidating and expanding economic cooperation for mutual and long-term benefit and cooperation in the fields of culture, education, health, sports, and science and technology and commits both countries not to allow the use of their territories for activities harmful to the national security and interest of the other.”

“The friendship of our two countries is now going to start on a new footing with both countries being democratic constitutions, it is a very good beginning with the establishment of a new Constitution”
  In India analysts see the updating of the treaty with Bhutan as a start to the restructuring of India’s relations with its South Asian neighbours. They see it as a departure from a policy that was established during the colonial era and describe it as a modernisation of Indian foreign policy. “India-Bhutan relations, based on the foundation of shared interests and mutually beneficial cooperation, have become an exemplary model of good neighbourly relations,” Mr. Sarna said. “They symbolise the belief that the people of South Asia share a common destiny.”

Political analysts also see the new approach in India’s foreign policy as expanding the political parameters in relations. Bhutan sees it as a natural step in its expanding relations with India that has matured over the years. It becomes more relevant in a political scenario that is undergoing major transformation.

“From a guiding role upon Bhutan’s first step to modernisation we now stand as close friends and equal partners in the global arena,” His Majesty said. “Today, Bhutan is undergoing unprecedented and profound changes. Bhutanese, in a time of peace and prosperity, have the unique opportunity to build a political system that is suited to our own needs and one which ensures a truly functioning democracy.”

His Majesty the fifth Druk Gyalpo, who met President APJ Abdul Kalam, Prime Minister Dr. Manmohan Singh, the UPA leader Mrs. Sonia Gandhi, and also talked to Indian leaders from every section of society, said that it had always been a conviction of his father, the fourth Druk Gyalpo, that a successful democracy was fundamental to achieving the goals of Gross National Happiness. “If Bhutan can build a strong democratic system then our future is forever secure,” he said.

Apart from spreading its diplomatic horizons in a globalised world, Bhutan’s experience has shown the need to be conscious of its domestic responsibilities like its internal security at a time when growing insurgency and increased militancy had disrupted its own borders. A small and compact armed force is seen as being vital for Bhutan’s internal security as the kingdom tries to preserve the peace that is a strong element of its image.

“Not that we expect Bhutan to ever go to war with its neighbours,” said a political analyst in Delhi. “But Bhutan must be prepared as the region is becoming more turbulent. The treaty gives Bhutan the flexibility to strengthen its own armed forces as it sees fit.”

The treaty will be ratified by His Majesty the King and President Abdul Kalam within a month after the signing. An advocate of the Supreme Court, Mr. Venugopal, described the India-Bhutan Treaty as a great step forward, particularly with Bhutan’s Constitution to be adopted. “The friendship of our two countries is now going to start on a new footing with both countries being democratic constitutions,” he said. “It is a very good beginning with the establishment of a new Constitution.”

His Majesty the King added that the treaty also symbolised India’s commitment to liberty, global equality and justice, and confirmed its role as a leader in international affairs. Indian analysts also interpreted the Treaty as a signal to its neighbours as India becomes one of the major political and economic powers in the world.

It was in an atmosphere of tremendous goodwill that His Majesty was received in India on his first visit as the Druk Gyalpo. Received warmly as a head of state, Indian leaders called on His Majesty with a sense of familiarity that conveyed a continuity in the rapport that has characterised the relations between Bhutan and India.

His Majesty said that he proudly inherited from the fourth Druk Gyalpo the immense legacy of Indo-Bhutan friendship and cooperation and the duty to further strengthen it. “I hope that this unique alliance born from the efforts of the leaders of the two nations would be inherited by the people and that affection and friendship between the two peoples would henceforth be the bond that holds our destinies together forever.”